The McCoy pottery company produced a range of charming and collectible cookie jars, and among the most sought-after is the smiley face cookie jar. These cheerful pieces are a testament to mid-century modern design and hold a special place in the hearts of many collectors. This guide delves into the world of McCoy smiley face cookie jars, exploring their history, variations, value, and how to identify genuine pieces.
What Makes McCoy Smiley Face Cookie Jars So Collectible?
Several factors contribute to the enduring popularity and collectability of McCoy smiley face cookie jars:
- Nostalgia: These jars evoke a sense of nostalgia for a simpler time, reminding many of childhood memories and family traditions. The cheerful design instantly brings a smile to the face.
- Mid-Century Modern Design: The simple, iconic smiley face design is a perfect example of the clean lines and playful aesthetic of mid-century modern design, a style that continues to be highly appreciated today.
- Rarity and Variations: While not exceedingly rare, specific variations in color, glaze, and even the expression of the smiley face can significantly impact the value of a jar.
- Quality Craftsmanship: McCoy pottery was known for its quality, and these cookie jars are often well-preserved, showcasing the craftsmanship of the era.
What are the Different Types of McCoy Smiley Face Cookie Jars?
Identifying the specific type of McCoy smiley face cookie jar you own can help determine its value. Variations exist in:
- Colors: Common colors include yellow, but you might also find rarer variations in other shades.
- Glaze: The type and finish of the glaze can vary, impacting the overall appearance and feel of the jar.
- Facial Features: While the basic smiley face is consistent, subtle differences in the eyes, mouth, and overall expression can exist between jars.
- Size: While generally consistent, slight size variations may occur due to the handmade nature of the pottery.
Unfortunately, comprehensive photographic documentation of every McCoy smiley face variation is not readily available publicly. Referencing online auction sites and collector forums can be helpful in identifying specific subtypes.
How Much is a McCoy Smiley Face Cookie Jar Worth?
The value of a McCoy smiley face cookie jar is highly dependent on its condition, rarity, and the specific variation. Factors influencing value include:
- Condition: A jar in pristine condition, without chips, cracks, or significant wear, will command a higher price.
- Rarity: As mentioned, certain color variations or subtle design differences can make a jar more valuable.
- Demand: The current market demand for these jars will also affect their value.
It's impossible to provide a precise value without examining a specific jar. Checking completed listings on online auction sites like eBay can give you a general idea of current market prices for similar McCoy smiley face cookie jars.
How Can I Tell if My McCoy Smiley Face Cookie Jar is Authentic?
Authenticating McCoy pottery requires careful examination. Look for:
- Maker's Mark: Genuine McCoy pieces typically have a maker's mark, though the specific mark can vary depending on the production period.
- Glaze Quality: McCoy pottery is known for its high-quality glaze. Uneven or poorly applied glaze can suggest a reproduction.
- Overall Construction: Examine the jar for inconsistencies in shape or construction that might indicate a counterfeit.
If you are unsure about the authenticity of your McCoy smiley face cookie jar, seeking the opinion of an experienced McCoy pottery collector or appraiser is recommended.
Where Can I Find McCoy Smiley Face Cookie Jars?
McCoy smiley face cookie jars can be found in various places:
- Online Auction Sites: Websites like eBay frequently feature listings for these collectible jars.
- Antique Malls and Shops: Antique shops and malls often carry vintage pottery, and you might find a McCoy smiley face cookie jar among their offerings.
- Thrift Stores and Flea Markets: These locations can be treasure troves of vintage finds, but require more searching.
- Collector Forums and Groups: Connecting with online communities of McCoy collectors can provide leads on where to find these jars.
This guide provides a starting point for your exploration into the world of McCoy smiley face cookie jars. Remember that research and careful examination are crucial when buying or selling these collectible pieces. Happy hunting!
